If you’re choosing between ISDIN Eryfotona Actinica SPF 50+ and Tatcha The Silk Peony Eye Cream, the first thing to know is that they aren’t meant to do the same job. ISDIN is a face sunscreen focused on sun protection, while Tatcha is an eye cream focused on hydration and smoothing. Both have strong reviews, but the better choice depends on what your skin needs most.
What Each Product Is
The product description states that ISDIN Eryfotona Actinica SPF 50+ is a broad spectrum UVA/UVB sunscreen with SPF 50+. It includes Vitamin E antioxidant, DNA Repairsomes, and Zinc Oxide. The product description also states it has a fast-absorbing, moisturizing, lightweight formula made for the face and is described as perfect under makeup.
The product description states that Tatcha The Silk Peony Eye Cream is a healthy aging eye cream with a melting texture. It is described as releasing a double shield of hydration with line-smoothing liquid silk and moisture-locking Japanese white peony. The product description also states it smooths and blurs, and that it is designed for comfort around the delicate eye area.
Texture and How They Feel on the Skin
The product description states that ISDIN is lightweight, moisturizing, and fast-absorbing.
Reviewers have noted that it applies smoothly and feels creamy, comfortable, and lightweight. Several reviewers also said it becomes invisible once applied and does not feel sticky or greasy. One reviewer mentioned it dries immediately.
However, reviewers have also noted that it may feel drying for some people. One reviewer shared that after wearing it throughout the day, their skin became dry and developed flaking around the mouth and sometimes the nose. That same reviewer also said it could settle into fine lines.
The product description states that Tatcha has a unique melting texture and is a cushiony balm designed to melt upon application.
Reviewers have noted that it feels silky, soothing, and lightweight without feeling heavy or greasy. Some reviewers described it as rich, thick, and hydrating, while still being comfortable around sensitive under-eye skin.
How They Look on the Skin
Reviewers have noted that ISDIN can leave a nice finish and may not leave a white cast. Some reviewers specifically said there was no white cast, while one reviewer mentioned a slight white cast on an olive complexion. Another reviewer shared that it can make skin look odd in photos, but said applying powder helped.
Reviewers have noted that Tatcha can leave the under-eye area looking smooth and hydrated. One reviewer described it as leaving a silky, glowing look where it was applied, and another described it as having a soft sheen.
Wearing Them Under Makeup
The product description states that ISDIN is made for the face and is perfect under makeup.
Reviewers have noted that it sits well over moisturizer and works well under makeup. One reviewer said their makeup glides on smoothly, and another reviewer mentioned no pilling.
The product description states that Tatcha smooths and blurs.
Reviewers have noted that makeup layers easily on top of it. One reviewer said it left the under-eye area hydrated while still allowing makeup to apply over it.
However, reviewers have noted that it may pill if the under-eye area is not completely clean or if it is applied over other products or reapplied.
What Reviewers Said About Irritation and Sensitivity
Reviewers have noted that ISDIN feels non-irritating and comfortable on the skin. One reviewer described it as fragrance free to them, and another said it doesn’t irritate their skin.
Reviewers have noted that Tatcha feels gentle and non-irritating, including for sensitive skin. Multiple reviewers mentioned no irritation, redness, or burning sensations.
Size and Value Impressions
Reviewers have noted that ISDIN comes in a 3.4 oz bottle and described it as large compared to other sunscreens they’ve used. Reviewers also described it as expensive, but some felt the larger size helped it last longer.
Reviewers have noted that Tatcha is pricey, but several people said a little goes a long way. One reviewer said it lasts three months or more, and another reviewer mentioned that using a small amount helps it last a long time.
Maintenance Costs and Long-Term Use
The product description does not include details about maintenance costs for either product.
Final Thoughts and Recommendation
If you want a daily face sunscreen with broad spectrum SPF 50+ protection, ISDIN Eryfotona Actinica SPF 50+ stands out for its lightweight feel and makeup-friendly wear. Reviewers often praised how smoothly it applies and how comfortable it feels, but some people did mention dryness, flaking, or texture settling into fine lines over time.
If you want an under-eye product that focuses on hydration and smoothing, Tatcha The Silk Peony Eye Cream is a strong option. Reviewers frequently described it as soothing, gentle, and effective for hydration, with a smooth finish that can work well under makeup. The main drawback mentioned was the possibility of pilling if layered over other products or reapplied.
My recommendation is simple: choose ISDIN if your priority is sun protection for your face, and choose Tatcha if you want extra hydration and comfort for your under-eye area.
VSearch.com is a participant in various affiliate programs including Amazon Associates. We may earn a commission at no additional cost to you if you purchase qualifying products through the links on our website.
