Selecting a fitness tracker often comes down to what you want to measure and how much detail you need. The Garmin vívosmart 5 and Garmin Forerunner 255 both offer health and activity tracking, but they do so at different levels. Here’s a clear, grounded comparison based only on the product descriptions and the reviews provided.
Design and Comfort
The product description for the vívosmart 5 states that it has a brighter and larger display than the vívosmart 4, along with both a touchscreen and a button. It is described as comfortable and easy to use. The product description for the Forerunner 255 highlights a slim design with an always-on, full-color display that remains easy to read even in direct sunlight. It also comes in two sizes, 46 mm and 41 mm.
Reviewers of the vívosmart 5 mention mixed impressions regarding the band. One reviewer noted that the buckle positioning felt uncomfortable during typing until they reversed the band, which resolved the issue. Reviewers of the Forerunner 255 describe it as lightweight and comfortable for long runs or all-day wear.
Battery Life
According to the product description, the vívosmart 5 offers up to 7 days of battery life in smartwatch mode. The Forerunner 255 product description states that it provides up to 14 days in smartwatch mode and up to 30 hours in GPS mode.
Reviewers of the vívosmart 5 say the device charges quickly and holds a charge well. Reviewers of the Forerunner 255 consistently note long battery life, with some stating it lasts several days or longer depending on usage.
The product descriptions and reviews do not include information about maintenance costs for either device.
Health and Wellness Tracking
The vívosmart 5 product description states that it tracks respiration, Pulse Ox (where available), Body Battery levels, women’s health, hydration, stress, and heart rate. It also provides sleep scores and insights through the Garmin Connect app.
The Forerunner 255 product description explains that it offers sleep tracking, HRV status, a morning report summarizing wellness data, and performance insights such as training status.
Reviewers of the vívosmart 5 highlight accurate heart rate readings and detailed sleep tracking. A Forerunner 255 reviewer confirms the watch includes sleep tracking, though they did not personally use it.
Fitness and Activity Features
The vívosmart 5 product description lists built-in sports apps for walking, running, yoga, cardio, pool swimming, and more. It does not include built-in GPS but connects to a smartphone’s GPS for outdoor activities.
The Forerunner 255 product description states that it includes built-in GPS, adaptive training plans, race predictions, suggested daily workouts, and advanced training metrics when paired with compatible accessories.
Reviewers of the vívosmart 5 explain that connecting it to a phone allows detailed mapping and distance tracking in the Garmin Connect app. They also mention that automatic rep counting works but sometimes needs adjustments.
Reviewers of the Forerunner 255 frequently highlight accurate GPS tracking, helpful lap and pace reporting, and motivational achievement badges.
Smart Features
The vívosmart 5 product description states that it provides smart notifications for calls, texts, and calendar alerts when connected to a smartphone. It also includes incident detection and Assistance features when connected and configured.
The Forerunner 255 product description notes that it supports notifications, and certain models allow music storage through apps downloaded via Garmin Connect IQ.
Reviewers of the vívosmart 5 appreciate improved message readability and the ability to scroll and delete notifications on the device. Reviewers of the Forerunner 255 Music model describe using stored music during runs without needing their phone.
Durability and Everyday Use
The vívosmart 5 product description states that it is safe for swimming and showering.
The Forerunner 255 product description does not list water-rating details in this excerpt.
Reviewers of the vívosmart 5 report varied experiences with long-term software stability, with some users mentioning issues following app updates. Reviewers of the Forerunner 255 describe it as durable over long periods, with one reviewer noting years of reliable daily use.
User Impressions
Reviewers of the vívosmart 5 often praise its accuracy, detailed sleep tracking, long battery life, and useful features in the Garmin Connect app. Some reviewers report glitches following app updates.
Reviewers of the Forerunner 255 highlight accurate GPS performance, strong battery life, and helpful training features. A few reviewers say the watch menus can take time to learn or that they switched to alternate bands for comfort.
Final Thoughts
Both devices serve different needs based on the level of detail you want from your workouts and daily activity. The vívosmart 5 offers an easy, lightweight option for tracking steps, sleep, heart rate, and everyday activity. Its strengths, based on reviewer feedback, include accuracy and comfort once adjusted.
The Forerunner 255 provides a more advanced training experience, with built-in GPS, suggested workouts, race predictions, and training insights. Reviewers describe it as a strong companion for running and structured fitness routines.
If your goal is simple daily tracking with helpful wellness insights, the vívosmart 5 fits well. If you want deeper performance data for running or long-term training, the Forerunner 255 is the more powerful option.
VSearch.com is a participant in various affiliate programs including Amazon Associates. We may earn a commission at no additional cost to you if you purchase qualifying products through the links on our website.
